When we talk about the first person to act in a particular role we say he or she “created” that role. While not entirely accurate (hello, remember the writer?), “created” is as fair a word that one can find to express what an actor brings to a story. Imagine what Silence of the Lambs would have been like without Anthony Hopkins. Or The Lion in Winter without Katharine Hepburn. Can’t do it, can you?
How then do we appraise the “creation” of dramatic roles that are based on real people with actions and words recorded in recent memory? Is it a matter of mimicry? Joaquin Phoenix and Reese Witherspoon would win Oscars easily on that score. They both have the distinctive traits and mannerisms down cold, from the way Johnny Cash often held his guitar like a rifle to the particular way June Carter drawled vowels like those in “Wildwood Flower.”
The only way to judge such performances is, as with all acting, to gauge how often you are aware that these people are not who they are portraying. The challenge here is greater, especially when judged by fans who are intimately familiar with the comings, goings and appearances of such well-known figures as Johnny Cash and June Carter (or in last year’s case, Ray Charles). On this front, Phoenix and Witherspoon are impressive. From Cash’s bouts with rage and desperation to Carter’s quiet (and often not-all-that quiet) suffering and righteous indignation, their performances are genuine beyond mere copycats.
Highly recommended (Besides, how can you dislike a movie with this soundtrack?)
And a prediction: I’ve not seen any of the other nominees’ performances, but Reese Witherspoon will win the Oscar for Best Actress going away. Phoenix is good, but competition is too stiff.