Fearless predictions
All day I kicked around the idea of pegging an actual prediction on the Reds, beyond my lukewarm endorsement below. They are better this year, but there are better teams in the their division. But two things nagged at me all day.
First, no one seems to think that the Reds will improve in any aspect of the game. Everyone thinks that the Brewers and Pirates will improve, but not the Reds. That's unfair and short-sighted.
Second, every team in the NL Central has some serious questions to answer. Take the Cardinals. Will Scott Rolen's shoulder be able to keep his arm attached to his body for an entire season? How much will they miss Matt Morris? Can they mash on the ball like they have been if Jim Edmonds has to rest every other day to soak his joints? Now I would not put it past Tony LaRussa to pull a rabbit out of his hat (Abraham Nunez, anyone?), but these are serious questions.
Of the other three teams universally predicted to finish above the Reds, ALL have serious (but varied) starting pitching problems. Can the Astros make a go without Clemens? What do the Brewers do without Ben Sheets? What do the Cubs do without Wood AND Prior?
So, time for that fearless prediction I promised.
Cincinnati Reds: THIRD PLACE, National League Central.
That's right. THIRD. Here's why.
The pitching will be better. Harang and Claussen, with decent years last year under their belts, should be improved. Arroyo can be relied upon if nothing else to pitch six or seven innings every fifth day. The bullpen, even sans closer, will not be the sieve we've seen in recent years, stocked with kids who should be in AAA.
The defense will be better. Except perhaps for Encarnacion. Scott Hatteberg, whatever one thinks about his hitting, is better at first than Adam Dunn.
We know they can hit.
The wheels will fall off someone else's wagon. There are too many teams "ahead" of the Reds with nagging questions. Somebody is going to collapse. I hope it's Houston, but it's more likely to be the Brewers or the Cubs.
The Reds will be close at the All-Star break. They always are...well, maybe not to the break, but at least through May and part of June. Then they collapse. If they can buck that trend, Castellini and Krivsky will go get that stopper they need at the front of the rotation.
How's that for a baseball version of a Rube Goldberg machine?


