Do first novels have the best stories?
I've read numerous first novels this year. Part of this is comparison: how does my own work stack up to these other first efforts? Another part of this is that I've noticed that any novel that can be extended into a series is usually best in its first iteration, at least from a story perspective. What do you think?
Part of this is simply the natural progress of a series. You reach a point where you just can't tell a different story, or you keep telling the same one over and over. Think Murder, She Wrote or anything by Alex Cross and the later books by Patricia Cornwell. Some series longevity defies common sense. That's part of the reason that Greg Rucka is taking a hiatus from Queen & Country. The main character, who acts essentially in real time with world events, has been an active covert operative for six years. And that's just not feasible.
Another thing: the first novel is often the one the author spent the most time with. It's probably the story they most desperately wanted to tell for the longest time, the tale that demanded telling. That's apparent in John Grisham's A Time to Kill. Far superior to The Firm, Tom Cruise or not. (Actually, the movie of A Time to Kill is pretty miserable, too.)
Of course, this is not to say that first novels are the best written. No, what I've noticed, at least from what I've read and especially in the mystery genre is that first novels have the best stories. C. J. Box's Open Season was great, but the blurb on his second book turned me off. Now granted, that's the blurb. But if you can't get people to read past the blurb. A is for Alibi was a re-read for me, and I remember enjoying the series quite a bit after that, but A was strongest in my memory and was strong on a second read. The Cater Street Hangman was compelling; its successor, Callander Square, was an awful bore from the beginning. David Skibbins' High Priestess, on the other hand, was both a better story AND better written, I think, than Eight of Swords.
John Scalzi's The Ghost Brigades was a surprisingly strong sequel, though perhaps helped by not relating directly to its predecessor. I'm looking forward to picking up Robert Charles Wilson's Axis and seeing what's happening there.
I also wonder how many first published novels are really first written novels.
Playing: Copland, Symphony No. 3; New York Philharmonic, Leonard Bernstein. So far I've listened to about 90 CDs in my quest to make it through the whole collection. I've heard mostly classical so far, but that's the vast majority of what I've got. Next week I'll get more into the jazz and rock stuff.
Listening: Kingdom of Shadows, Alan Furst. I still plan to get a hard copy of Dark Star, but I need something to listen to at the gym.
Pipeline: The Second Novel has about 40,000 words and I can see the ending, which I am still trying to obstruct. We'll see. I've idled a bit on getting research together for the Third Novel, which starts on October 9 come hell or high water, but today I made my first research pile of articles, books and recordings that I need. This tower of sorts stands sentinel on the corner of my desk to remind to get cracking on the Second Novel because there's more to do.


